im a beginner and want to pet a puppies. i have schools from 6 am to 3 pm. so i have to left my pups alone during that time. but he will be free to go wandering in our yard. its about medium sized yard.
please your advice.
All of these breeds are working breeds so it's hard to answer, since really none of them are ideal for someone who is gone 6-3 during the week. All I can say for SURE is not to get a Siberian Husky. I own one and tried to work at the same time as raise her as a pup, and it was really, really difficult–and I'm NOT a first time puppy owner! My solution was that now I work from home, and spend all day with her, and eventually we are going to get another dog as a playmate, once she is at least 98% reliably trained and well behaved, but they need tons of attention and exercise outside of a yard for sure.
You may be best off with a Collie, but like I said, all three are working breeds and need lots of exercise, meaning, not necessarily space to run around, but regimented exercise with you, that seems like work: running, walking in a diciplined manner, and general training, at least while they are around 0 months to 1 1/2 years old. I'd advise that if you want one of these dogs, to get an older adult, that has gotten past his crazy energy phase. Or, to research a breed that doesn't need as much interaction and exercise. What the books say is right about these breeds, there is no way around their reaction to loneliness and desire for proper exercise. Out of the 3, a Collie might be the best fit, but I'd suggest getting another breed that is more suitable to your schedule for the dog's sake and yours…